Allegations of Research Misconduct
Research misconduct includes fabrication, falsification and plagiarism, as well as manipulation of authorship, citations or peer review. JCIS takes every allegation seriously and handles it confidentially, fairly and in line with COPE flowcharts.
Fabrication
Making up data, experiments or results.
Falsification
Manipulating data, code, images or processes so that results are not accurately represented.
Plagiarism
Using others' ideas, text, data or code without credit, including self-plagiarism.
Review manipulation
Fake reviewer identities, citation cartels or undisclosed relationships with reviewers.
How allegations are handled
- ReportSend the allegation with supporting evidence to the editor-in-chief at pustipada@uinsu.ac.id. Anonymous reports are considered if the evidence is specific.
- Preliminary checkThe editor verifies the evidence without disclosing the identity of the person who raised the concern.
- Response from authorsThe authors are informed and given the opportunity to explain.
- EscalationIf the explanation is unsatisfactory, the journal informs the authors' institution and asks it to investigate.
- OutcomeDepending on the findings: no action, correction, expression of concern, retraction, and a submission ban for the authors of up to three years.
