Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement
JCIS is committed to the highest standards of publication ethics. Our policies follow the Core Practices and guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the Indonesian national guidelines on scientific journal management. These duties apply to everyone involved in publishing: authors, editors, reviewers and the publisher.
Duties of editors
- Decide on publication solely on the manuscript's scientific merit, relevance and originality, without regard to the authors' race, gender, religion, nationality, institution or political view.
- Keep submitted manuscripts confidential and never use unpublished material for their own research.
- Recuse themselves from manuscripts where they have a conflict of interest and assign them to another editor.
- Investigate complaints and suspected misconduct promptly, following COPE flowcharts.
Duties of reviewers
- Help the editor reach a decision and help authors improve their work through constructive comments.
- Treat manuscripts as confidential documents and review them objectively.
- Point out relevant published work that has not been cited and report any substantial similarity with other papers.
- Decline to review when they have a conflict of interest or lack the required expertise or time.
Duties of authors
- Submit original work, cite the work of others accurately and obtain permission for reproduced material.
- Present data honestly; be ready to provide the underlying data or code on reasonable request.
- Do not submit the same manuscript to more than one journal at a time.
- List as authors only those who meet the authorship criteria, and disclose funding and conflicts of interest.
- Notify the editor promptly of any significant error found after submission or publication.
- Disclose any use of generative AI tools in the methods or acknowledgements; AI tools cannot be listed as authors.
Duties of the publisher
- PUSTIPADA UIN Sumatera Utara guarantees the editorial independence of the journal.
- Provides the infrastructure for open access, long-term preservation and secure manuscript handling.
- Supports editors in handling ethical issues, corrections and retractions.
Allegations of misconduct are handled according to our research misconduct policy. Concerns may be sent confidentially to the editor-in-chief at pustipada@uinsu.ac.id.
