Peer Review Process

Peer Review Process

JCIS uses a double-blind peer review: the identities of authors and reviewers are hidden from each other. Every manuscript that passes the initial screening is reviewed by at least two independent reviewers.

  1. Submission and screening (about 1 week)The editorial office checks scope, template compliance, completeness and similarity. Manuscripts that fail the screening are returned to the authors.
  2. Reviewer assignmentThe section editor invites at least two reviewers with relevant expertise and no conflict of interest.
  3. Peer review (about 3 weeks)Reviewers assess originality, method, results, clarity and references, and recommend a decision.
  4. Editorial decisionThe editor weighs the reviews and decides: accept, minor revision, major revision or reject.
  5. Revision (2 weeks for minor, 4 weeks for major)Authors revise and submit a response letter answering each comment point by point. Major revisions are usually sent back to the reviewers.
  6. Final decision, copyediting and layoutAccepted manuscripts are copyedited, laid out and proofread by the authors before publication.
  7. PublicationThe article is published online in the next available issue (April, August or December).
Accept

Publishable as is, or after editorial corrections only.

Minor revision

Small changes; the editor checks the revision.

Major revision

Substantial changes; the revision is reviewed again.

Reject

Not suitable for JCIS; the reasons are given to the authors.

The typical time from submission to first decision is 4–6 weeks. The editor-in-chief makes the final decision. Authors may appeal a decision once by writing to the editor with a reasoned argument.