Peer Review Process
JCIS uses a double-blind peer review: the identities of authors and reviewers are hidden from each other. Every manuscript that passes the initial screening is reviewed by at least two independent reviewers.
- Submission and screening (about 1 week)The editorial office checks scope, template compliance, completeness and similarity. Manuscripts that fail the screening are returned to the authors.
- Reviewer assignmentThe section editor invites at least two reviewers with relevant expertise and no conflict of interest.
- Peer review (about 3 weeks)Reviewers assess originality, method, results, clarity and references, and recommend a decision.
- Editorial decisionThe editor weighs the reviews and decides: accept, minor revision, major revision or reject.
- Revision (2 weeks for minor, 4 weeks for major)Authors revise and submit a response letter answering each comment point by point. Major revisions are usually sent back to the reviewers.
- Final decision, copyediting and layoutAccepted manuscripts are copyedited, laid out and proofread by the authors before publication.
- PublicationThe article is published online in the next available issue (April, August or December).
Accept
Publishable as is, or after editorial corrections only.
Minor revision
Small changes; the editor checks the revision.
Major revision
Substantial changes; the revision is reviewed again.
Reject
Not suitable for JCIS; the reasons are given to the authors.
The typical time from submission to first decision is 4–6 weeks. The editor-in-chief makes the final decision. Authors may appeal a decision once by writing to the editor with a reasoned argument.
