The Law of Obeying A Leader According to the Views of Abu Muhammad Al-Maqdisi Reviewed from Fiqh Siyasah

Misdin Arifin HM, Dirja Hasugian

Abstract


It has become an agreement among Sunni scholars that obeying the leader of the state is an obligation. The obligation to obey this applies to every Muslim leader whether he is cautious or not while not yet falling into real kufr. No one sneaks in this principle except the Khawarij and Mu'tazilah. But there is a figure named Abu Muhammad Al-Maqdisi who in principle has the same understanding as the Sunni scholars in the matter of the obligation to obey the leader even though they are acting arbitrarily against the people. The problem is that there is a statement from al-Maqdisi that shows the fall of the obligation to obey the leaders now, as if Muslim leaders have now apostatized from Islam so that they must not be obeyed or be loyal to them and are even obliged to fight. The formulation of the problem is: (1) how al-Maqdisi's views on obedience to the leader, (2) how the ulama's response to al-Maqdisi's views, (3) What is al-Maqdisi's view according to siyasah fiqh. This study aims to describe and describe the ai-Maqdisi thinking systematically. From this study it can be concluded that al-Maqdisi saw no adherence to the leaders of the Islamic world now because they had apostatized due to abandoning Islamic laws, therefore obliged to fight them according to their respective abilities. Many scholars opposed Al-Maqdisi's ideas but many supported them. However, if viewed from the perspective of the Siyasah fiqh, al-Maqdisi's thinking is incorrect, even very dangerous because it will cause a war between the government and the people so that the country will be chaotic.

Keywords


Obeying The Leader, Muhammad Al-Maqdisi, Siyasah Fiqh

Full Text:

PDF

References


Abdul Wahab. „Ilmu Ushuuli Al-Fiqh, Kairo : Maktabah al-Da‟wah al-Islamiyah 1942 M

Abu Jaib, Sa‟di al-Qamus al-Fiqhi Lugatan Wa Istilahan, Damaskus : Daru al-Fikri 1988 M ad-Dukhan, Usamah. “Ma Hia as-Sururiyah Wa Liman Tarji‟ Nisbatuha”, Artikel alauazm, 19-5-2015, http://www.alawazm.com

Adz-Dzahabi, Muhammad Ibnu Ahmad. Nuzhatu al-Fudhala`, Jeddah : Daru Al-Andalus Tt

Al Qazwaini, Muhammad Ibnu Yazid. Sunan Ibnu Majah, Beirut : Daru Al-Fikri T.t

Al-„Asqalaani, Ahmad Ibn Ali. Al-Ishaabah Fi Tamyiizi Al-Shahaabah, Beirut : Daaru Al-Jail 1412 H

Al-„Asqalaani, Ahmad Ibn Ali. Tahdzhiibu Al-Tahdziib, Beirut : Daru Al-Fikr 1984 M

al-„Asqalaani, Ibn Hajar. Fathu Al-Baari Syarhu Al-Shahiih Al-Bukhaari, Beirut Dar Al-Ma‟rifah 1379 H

Al-Baihaaqi, Ahmad Ibn Alhusain. Sunan Al-Baihaqi Al-Qubra, Makkah : Maktabah Daaru Al-Baaz 1994 M

al-Baihaqi, Ahmad Ibn al-Husain. As-Sunan al-Kubra, Haidar Abad : Majlis Da‟irah al-Ma‟rifah an-Nizamiyah 1344 H

Al-Baihaqi, Ahmad Ibn Husain. Manaqib Al-Syafi‟I, Kairo : Maktabah Daru Al-Turast TTh

Al-Barbahari, Hasan Ibn Ali. Syarhu As-Sunnah, Kairo : Al-Hadyu Al-Muhammadi 1429 H/2008M

al-Barqaawi, „Ashim Ibn Thaahir. Al-Diimuqroothiyah Diinun ( TTP : Minbar Al-Tauhid Wa Al-Jihaad T.Tn

al-Barqawi, „Ashim Ibn Muhammad. al-Isyrāqāt Fi Su‟āli sawwāqah, Penjara Sawwaqah : Minbar at-Tauhid Wa al-Jihad 1417 H

al-Barqawi, „Ashim Ibn Muhammad. Kasyfu Syubuhāti al-Mujādilin `an `Asākiri al-Syirki Wa Anshāri al-Qawānin, Penjara Sawwaqah : Minbaru at-Tauhid wal Jihad 1416 H

Al-Barqawi, „Aashim Ibn Thaahir. Mereka Mujahid Tapi Salah Langkah, Ter. Abu Sulaiman, Solo : Jazera 2007 M

al-Barqawi, „Ashim Ibn Muhammad. al-Kawasyifu al-Jaliyah Fi Kufri al-Daulah as-

al-Barqawi, „Ashim Ibn Muhammad. Hadzihi „Aqidatuna, Minbaru At-Tauhid Wal Jihad Jumada Al-Tsaniyah 1418 H

al-Barqawi, „Ashim Ibn Muhammad. Kasyfu an-Niqab „An Syari‟ati al-Ghaab , Minbar Tauhid Dan Jihad

Al-Bukhari, Muhammad bin Ismail. Shahih Al-Bukhari, Daru Thauqu An-Najah 1422 H

al-Darimi, ِ¸ Abdullah Ibn Abdurrahman. Sunan al-Darami, Beirut : Darul Kutub al-Arobi 1407 H

al-Fayumi, Ahmad Ibn Muhammad. al-Misbah al-Munir, Beirut : al-Maktabah al-„Ilmiah T.Th

Al-Ghazali, al-Tibr al-Masbūk Fī Nasīhati al-Mulūk, Beirut : Darul Kutub al-„Ilmiyah 1409 H

al-Harisi, Jamal Ibn Furaihan. al-Ajwibah al-Mufidah „An as‟ilati al-Manahij al-Jadidah, (Kairo : al-Maktabah al-Muhammadi 2008 M

Ibn Abdul Karim al-„Aql, Nasir. Diraasaat fi al-ahwa wa al-firaq wa al-bida‟, Riyad : Daru Kunuj Isybilia 1432 H

Ibn Faris, Ahmad. Mu‟jam Maqayisi Al-Lugah, TTP : Darul Fikr 1979 M

Ibn Haadi Al-Madkhali, Rabi‟. Syarhu Usuuli Al-Sunnah, Kairo : Maktabah Al-Hadyu Al-Muhammadi 2008 M

Ibn Hajjaaj, Muslim. Shahīh Muslim, Beirut Daaru Al-Ihya Al-Turaast al-„Arabi T.Th

Ibn Ibrahim, Abdullah. Mafhumu At-Tha‟ah Wa Al-„Isyhyan, Riyad : Darul Muslim 1416 H

Ibn Jarir, Muhammad. Jaami‟ al-Bayan Fi Ta‟wili Al-Qur‟an, T.T.P : Mu‟assasah al-Risalah 2000 M

Ibn Mathar Al-„Utaibi, Sa‟ad. Maqalat Fi Al-Siyasah Al-Syar‟iyah, Riyad : Majalah Al-Bayan Markaz al-Buhuts Wa Al-Dirasat Al-Islamiyah 1438 H

Ibn Shalih, Muhammad. Al-Ta‟liq „Ala Risalati Rafi‟ Al-Asaathiin Fi Hukmi Al Ittishal Bi Al-Salathin, Riyad : Madarul Wathan 1430 H

Ibn Syaibahai-Kufi, Abdullah Ibn Muhammad. Mushannaf Ibn al-Syaibah, Riyad : Maktabah ar-Rusyd

Iqbal, Muhammad. Fiqh Siyasah, Jakarta : Prenadamedia Group 2016 M

Iqbal, Muhammad. Pemikiran Politik Islam Dari Masa Klasik Hingga Indonesia Kontemporer, Jakarta : Prenada Media 2015 M

Jaritsah, Ali. Al-Ittijāhāt Al-Fikriyah Al-Mu‟āshirah, Al-Mansurah : Daru Al-Wafaa‟ 1990

M Karim Zaidan, Abdu. Al Usulu Ad-Da‟wah, Bagdad : Mu‟assah Ar-Risalah 1975 M Khallaaf,

M. Ridwan Hasbi, “ Nilai-nilai Oposisi dalam Hadis Nabawi,” dalam Ushuluddin, Vol. XXII No. 2, Juli 2014

Pusat Bahasa Departemen Pendidikan Nasional, Kamus Bahasa Indonesia, ( Jakarta 2008)

Qutb, Sayyid. Fi Dzilāli Alquran, Beirut Dāru al-Syurūq 2003 M

Rabi‟ Ibn Haadi Al-Madkhali, Syarhu Usuuli Al-Sunnah, ( Kairo : Maktabah Al-Hadyu Al-Muhammadi 2008 M), h.66

Sa‟udiyah, Minbar at-Tauhid Wa al-Jihad 1421 H

Susanta, Ija. Politik Hukum Islam, Bandung : Pustaka Setia 2014 M Taimiyah, Ibn. al-Siy āsah al-Syar‟iyah, Beirut : Darul Afak al-Jadidah ttp://www.islamist-movements.com/12175.

Ulama‟ al-Najad Al-A‟lam, Al-Durar Al-Sunniyah, TTP : 1996 M

Wizaratu al-Awqaf wa asyu‟un al-Islamiah ,al-Mausu‟ah al-Fiqhiyah al-Kuwaitiyah, Cet.Ke1 (Mesir : Daru as-Safwah 1404-1427 H), h.193.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.7006/attafahum.v2i2.5175

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2018 AT-TAFAHUM: Journal of Islamic Law

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

 
 
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License
Based on a work at http://jurnal.uinsu.ac.id/index.php/attafahum/
 
Publisher:
Postgraduate Program
Universitas Islam Negeri Sumatera Utara